limitations of scientific knowledge

limitations of scientific knowledge

Written Assignment: Biology and Technology in the Real World (this is a graded assignment due by 11:59pm on Sunday, 4/23/17)

This assignment addresses course outcomes 1-4:

recognize and explain how the scientific method is used to solve problems
make observations and discriminate between scientific and pseudoscientific explanations
weigh evidence and make decisions based on strengths and limitations of scientific knowledge and the scientific method
use knowledge of biological principles, the scientific method, and appropriate technologies to ask relevant questions, develop hypotheses, design and conduct experiments, interpret results, and draw conclusions
1. Select one of the topics listed below.

2. Find at least three information sources related to the topic. All three sources must be cited in-text and listed in the references portion of the paper, all in APA format. You can find assistance with searching for articles at the UMUC Library Subject Guides at http://libguides.umuc.edu/science.

3. Write a 750-1500 word paper, excluding references and title page. You must read the information sources that you find and summarize the information in your own words, addressing each of the questions and expectations for your chosen topic (SEE BELOW – THERE ARE THREE TOPICS FROM WHICH YOU MUCT CHOOSE) AND provide an analysis of the information and your opion of it, along with a defense of your opinion. Extensive quotes from the article are unacceptable. Use APA style for citing references, see https://www.umuc.edu/library/libhow/apa_tutorial.cfm

4. Post your assignment to the Assignment folder by the due date listed in the course schedule.

5. The grading rubric for this assignment appears at the end of this posting.

Topics (select one of the three topics below!!)

a) Genetically modified organisms (GMOs). What is the purpose genetic engineering of crop plants and domestic animals? Briefly explain how GMOs are created. What foods in your supermarket contain GMOs? Are foods that contain GMOs safe for human consumption? What types of regulations exist for these foods? Clearly explain your reasoning for each answer.

b) Stem cells. Your friend had a spinal cord injury after a bad car accident. The medical team has decided that he is a good candidate for a clinical trial using stem cell therapy. Your friend has not had a biology course since high school, so you decide to write him a letter sharing your knowledge of stem cells. Include in your letter a description of the biology of stem cells and how these cells are unique from other cells. Contrast the different types of stem cells, including pros and cons of each. Explain how stems cells are can be used to treat diseases and injury, with special focus on spinal cord injuries. Conclude with your own opinion.

c) Fracking (hydraulic fracturing) and tar sands (oil sands). With society’s dependence on nonrenewable fossil fuels, the oil & gas industry is turning to the use of hydraulic fracturing and tar (oil) sands to extract natural gas and oil respectively. A friend asks you “What’s all this controversy in the news about fracking and tar sands?” Briefly explain to your friend how hydraulic fracturing and tar (oil) sands are used to obtain these fossil fuels. Then, in more detail, describe the environmental problems that may result from these processes and why they are controversial. Issues that may be addressed involves, but are not limited to, water, air and soil pollution, effects on human health, effects on other species and natural ecosystems. Finally, give your opinions on possible solutions to these environmental problems, with your reasoning backed by the references that you studied.

Grading Rubric:

Content=40 points

36-40 points: The information obtained from a minimum of three information sources is summarized clearly, accurately and well organized in your own words. All information sources are credible and relevant to the requirement for the chosen topic.

30-35 points: The information obtained from only two information sources is summarized and/or some minor issues with clarity, accuracy, and organization of information and/or one information source is not credible and/or relevant and/or more than a few direct quotes.

20-29 points: The information obtained from only one information source is summarized and/or major issues with clarity, accuracy, and organization of information and/or mostly direct quotes.

0-19 points: No information sources are summarized, and/or none of the sources are credible and relevant, and/or all direct quotes.

40

= Content Total

Contribution=40 points

36-40 points: All questions and requirements for chosen topic are addressed and own ideas are expressed, analyzed and defended based on knowledge learned from literature research.

30-35 points: One of the questions or requirements for chosen topic is not addressed, and/or minimal description and analysis of own ideas, and/or minimal connection between own ideas and what is learned from literature research.

20-29 points: Several of the questions or requirements for chosen topic are not addressed, and/or missing description and analysis of own ideas, and/or no connection between own ideas and what is learned from literature search.

0-19 points: Most of the questions and requirements for chosen topic are not addressed and no description and analysis of own ideas.

40

= Contribution Total

Grammar/Spelling=10 points

9-10 points: Less than 3 minor spelling/grammatical errors

7-8 points: 4-7 minor spelling/grammatical errors

5-6 points: 8-12 spelling/grammatical errors

0-4 points: More than 13 spelling/ grammatical errors.

10

=Grammar/Spelling Total

References= 5 points

5 points: At least three references listed at the end AND cited in-text references in correct APA format.

4 points: Missing one reference, and/or minor problems with APA format, and/or missing in-text references.

2 points: Missing several references and/or references not in APA format.

0 points: No references included.

5

=References Total

Length of Paper = 5 points

5 points: Paper is between 750 and 1500 words

4 points: Paper is between 600-749 or 1501-1700 words

3 points: Paper is between 400-599 or 1701 – 1999 words

0 points: Paper is less than 399 or more than 2000 words

5

= Length of Paper Total